Talk:Achievements: Difference between revisions

From Sourcebook Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
 
(11 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Did we kill 20 orcs yet? --[[User:Msallen|Msallen]]
Some of the ones in "pending" are actually approved. Especially Eric's new(ish) stuff. -gm
: No, there were no achievements back when you fought that first group. If you kill less than ten while you're in the swamp, I'll eat my hat. -gm
:I cleaned up the ones marked as approved and this comment was made about a year ago. Were there any others that never got marked as approved?--[[User:Bartley|Bartley]] ([[User talk:Bartley|talk]]) 17:39, 21 May 2016 (EDT)
:: In fact, the swamp seems a LOT more dangerous since the last time you guys were there, just judging by the frequency of hostile encounter. -gm
==What really happened? Together maybe we can remember==
Did the Silverwalkers' Quest Notes completely gloss over killing that dragon? Or is this a misentry? -[[User:Slitherrr|Slitherrr]]


Accidentally deleted a bunch when I moved em a few revs back, but all is well now. -[[User:Slitherrr|Slitherrr]]
I couldn't confirm from quest note screen shots, but probably at least some in [[Team_MeFight_Fifty-Fifth_Session|Gnob's Folly vs Mantatlus]] had the requisite 10 buffs for '''PUMP (clap) YOU UP'''--[[User:Bartley|Bartley]] ([[User talk:Bartley|talk]]) 17:27, 21 May 2016 (EDT)
:Also, should xorry get Iron Stomach? That poison was technically never supposed to be ingested. -[[User:Slitherrr|Slitherrr]]
:: Yes. Drinking poison definitely counts.


Does Kib qualify for Collecting Cobwebs if he hasn't used Uncanny Dodge? It's probably a moot point anyway, though, since he'll most likely gain a level before he gets his cohort. -[[User:Slitherrr|Slitherrr]]
----
: The second part you said, about the cohort.
"Have 250 maximum hp and lose them all" -- When does trigger? When you have exactly 250 maximum HP and go into negatives? When at least 250 hp and go to (max - 250) hp? When you have at least 250 hp and go into negatives? -[[User:Slitherrr|slitherrr]] ([[User talk:Slitherrr|talk]])
 
----
{{talk|
Did the Silverwalkers end up leaving Grrl? I never saw them swing around and pick him up. -[[User:Slitherrr|slitherrr]] ([[User talk:Slitherrr|talk]])
''Cleared more stuff.''
: I'm pretty sure he was left after blindly running into the underdark in fear. So I guess it's more of a MIA, presumed dead than confirmed killed. -[[User:Bartley|Bartley]] ([[User talk:Bartley|talk]]) 16:07, 30 May 2016 (EDT)
|[[User:Slitherrr|Slitherrr]] 20:52, 23 April 2010 (EDT)
}}
 
 
 
 
{{talk|It could be slightly less, yeah, but it's really, really hard to follow these talk pages for people outside of the conversation. I'm just a stickler for trying to make sense of what is being discussed and in what order. It may not be something to use, but I thought I would put it out there for any interested parties. :)
 
I can add a template parser extension and likely convince this to work more automatically. If I do that for our wiki at work, I'll share it here, too. :)
 
''Edit'': Let me add that I was actually intending these talk "blips" to be used temporarily inside page content to ask questions and then be deleted when the questions are remedied. A not-perfect example would be at the end of this topic: [[Bethnalay#On_The_Away_Team.27s_Return_From_the_Tomb]]
|[[User:Mattie|Mattie]] 17:57, 29 April 2010 (EDT)
|indent=4}}
 
 
== Prestigious Maximus ==
 
:: Hmmmmm... What class are we trying to cheat our way to? Defender? -gm
::: It's not cheating if the GM approves! :) I don't have any in mind. I haven't found any Prestige Classes that work very well for Mose, even missing a prereq. Without skill points at all and being a Paladin, he's fairly limited and none may even apply even with a relaxing. Maybe skipping an exalted feat for one of those crummy exalted prestige classes? But I haven't thought about those much since they're pretty bad. They might add flavor for Mose even if not much power. Still-- even if Mose can't use the reward, it might help one of the other players, though. Defender is good, but will be some time before Mose could try it. Field Marshal could happen, too, and is fairly interesting. (shrug) Just spices things up a bit.  -[[User:Mattie|Mattie]]
:::: Field Marshall actually cannot happen, as it is at the very least nationality exclusive. If you're committed to abandoning Pally, then you might as well just multi to a base class. Maybe even Fighter if you were looking for a way to grab feats for another prestige. (Fighter 1 and 2 grant feat levels)
::::: Although, as defender would work against more fully specializing your core strength (mobility and damage dealing), it seems like a not-Mattie choice, although I personally think it's not a terrible pick up as it allow for some versatility in dealing with threats, or even the option to rush to a critical area and then hold it. Though, generally it seems the staying rooted part of the defender precludes the movement boots and shifting that are the strengths of the Templar. -gm
:::::: Ah, didn't know FM had an extra requirement of being from a special location (hard to tell since all prestige classes are worded somewhat like that). There are some WotC prestige classes that Mose might qualify for, but no guarantee you'll consider them and they're not good enough to fight for anyway. Besides Paladin, only flavor-appropriate (and underpowered) path would be for Mose to seek Divine Crusader (Travel), which he arguably qualifies for without the Achievement. Really Templar should have just been 10 levels so Mose wouldn't feel so lost. :) -[[User:Mattie|Mattie]]
 
Oh, and shiftiness of the timing and reward aside, I think it is a good achievement overall. -gm
: Thanks! :) For the record, the worst/shiftiest abuse of this Achievement's reward would probably be to (ruin a character) and ignore the size requirement for the [http://www.wizards.com/default.asp?x=dnd/iw/20030914a War Hulk class] (bottom of page). -[[User:Mattie|Mattie]]
:1. Enlarge  plus perm plus xp cost
:2. No.

Latest revision as of 20:07, 30 May 2016

Some of the ones in "pending" are actually approved. Especially Eric's new(ish) stuff. -gm

I cleaned up the ones marked as approved and this comment was made about a year ago. Were there any others that never got marked as approved?--Bartley (talk) 17:39, 21 May 2016 (EDT)

What really happened? Together maybe we can remember

Did the Silverwalkers' Quest Notes completely gloss over killing that dragon? Or is this a misentry? -Slitherrr

I couldn't confirm from quest note screen shots, but probably at least some in Gnob's Folly vs Mantatlus had the requisite 10 buffs for PUMP (clap) YOU UP--Bartley (talk) 17:27, 21 May 2016 (EDT)

"Have 250 maximum hp and lose them all" -- When does trigger? When you have exactly 250 maximum HP and go into negatives? When at least 250 hp and go to (max - 250) hp? When you have at least 250 hp and go into negatives? -slitherrr (talk)

Did the Silverwalkers end up leaving Grrl? I never saw them swing around and pick him up. -slitherrr (talk)

I'm pretty sure he was left after blindly running into the underdark in fear. So I guess it's more of a MIA, presumed dead than confirmed killed. -Bartley (talk) 16:07, 30 May 2016 (EDT)
Retrieved from "https://wiki.memphisgamers.com/index.php?title=Talk:Achievements&oldid=17945"