Talk:Arcane Disciple: Difference between revisions

From Sourcebook Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
(pros/cons)
Line 2: Line 2:
: As you can imagine, I fell in love with it at first sight. I look forward to a AD/Sorc/DD monster spellcaster build. -gm
: As you can imagine, I fell in love with it at first sight. I look forward to a AD/Sorc/DD monster spellcaster build. -gm
:: So, trades the domain spell for a lower-level Arcane spell, and turn/rebuke for bonus feats? I'm not very familiar with clerics. -[[User:Slitherrr|Slitherrr]]
:: So, trades the domain spell for a lower-level Arcane spell, and turn/rebuke for bonus feats? I'm not very familiar with clerics. -[[User:Slitherrr|Slitherrr]]
::: There are some subtle comparisons to be made here.
:::*Pros:
:::** You get bonus metamagic/item feats (5 of them total)
:::** Much better spell choice: You get access to 9 spells from Magic domain + 20 arcane top-picks (instead of 18 pre-chosen spells from 2 domains).
:::*** Minor diff for L9 spells: No 9th level arcane spells means you have one less 9th level spell choice than a cleric with two carefully-chosen domains (traded for a few extra 8th-level arcane picks). Magic domain does give you Mage's Disjunction, though.
:::*Cons:
:::** No domain abilities
:::** No turn/rebuke
:::** Lowered hitdice from d8 to d6
:::** ?? Spell per day reduction? I'm not sure if you can still use Magic domain spells (or arcane spells) in a cleric's normal domain spell memorization slot. If not, that's a pretty big ding to have fewer spells you can memorize a day.
:::Anything else? -[[User:Mattie|Mattie]]

Revision as of 03:16, 5 April 2011

This is pretty cool. --Msallen

As you can imagine, I fell in love with it at first sight. I look forward to a AD/Sorc/DD monster spellcaster build. -gm
So, trades the domain spell for a lower-level Arcane spell, and turn/rebuke for bonus feats? I'm not very familiar with clerics. -Slitherrr
There are some subtle comparisons to be made here.
  • Pros:
    • You get bonus metamagic/item feats (5 of them total)
    • Much better spell choice: You get access to 9 spells from Magic domain + 20 arcane top-picks (instead of 18 pre-chosen spells from 2 domains).
      • Minor diff for L9 spells: No 9th level arcane spells means you have one less 9th level spell choice than a cleric with two carefully-chosen domains (traded for a few extra 8th-level arcane picks). Magic domain does give you Mage's Disjunction, though.
  • Cons:
    • No domain abilities
    • No turn/rebuke
    • Lowered hitdice from d8 to d6
    • ?? Spell per day reduction? I'm not sure if you can still use Magic domain spells (or arcane spells) in a cleric's normal domain spell memorization slot. If not, that's a pretty big ding to have fewer spells you can memorize a day.
Anything else? -Mattie